09 February 2013

Labels





Labeling is something I've always detested. Along the same lines as what I mentioned in my earlier post - "Sexuality" - I find that labeling is society's futile and immoral attempt at defining the undefinable.

What does it mean to be 'gay'?  Does it mean you're a butch, manly woman, or an effeminate, flamboyant man?  If you're gay, do you have to have to be interested in fashion and theater?  Of course not.  These are stereotypes - and I find that people seem to have the understanding that stereotypes which aren't blatantly denigrating are somehow acceptable.  The stereotypes associated with homosexuality may not intrinsically state that it's inferior to heterosexuality, but when it creates an expectation for a gay man to be fashionable (and conversely, for a straight man to be unfashionable), it becomes completely disparaging.

The image that society views when hearing "dyke" or "queer" will always be wrong.  It will be wrong for as long as it has a stereotype for gays.  There is no such thing as a "gay" personality, or a "gay" look.  Personality is not defined by sexuality.

This brings me to the problem within the gay community itself, and the problem of its rampant self-labeling.  I've heard a gay man once explain his interest in interior designing with, "it's because I'm gay!"  See my above paragraphs for my response to that. While I have no problem with being called a twink simply because I'm young and cute, the image of my personality is not something that should ever be based on the label of "twink", or "bear".

If you think that I'm a "preppy party boy...who will most likely get drunk and flirty (likely with an older guy)" and "think its cute to act dumb and...idolize Paris Hilton or Britney Spears," then you are sorely mistaken, 'mike t' from yahoo.answers. "Gaydar" is applicable only to outward mannerisms (effeminacy or butch-ness) - which is not equitable to sexuality.  Gay men and women come in all colors of their rainbow, and that is something that should neither be celebrated or ostracized. Society must simply come to the realization that sexuality does not create difference between people.


https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh8pXQ5K1lLEO7TGJGc7q2drfOKOBXed8qHorEOGfDl0Pd3vF4mKTTA4DK8qEJBo7aoFCZSDIKwvT-ezxEh-rxxE3uAQoBrBWuCTTAFSYQ06ubundpZdhG9EYNRCGdMltSuF9oYTZq0NiM/s640/blogger-image--907807555.jpg
Is he gay? or straight? or really even a man? There is no ability - nor necessity - to determine.


Gay pride parades are what I find as the epitome of detrimental labeling.  They advocate flamboyance, then label it as the representation of the gay community.  This will never be beneficial to reaching acceptance of homosexuality, despite the intrinsic benefits of the community they create.

Why would someone proclaim their pride in being gay any more than they would proclaim their pride in being human?  Both are equally insignificant in terms of actual identity.

4 comments:

  1. Have you ever been to a pride parade?

    In real life, pride parades are NOTHING like they seem like on TV/media. Media only picks up the most ridiculous floats/people because that is what people are interested in.

    In truth, Pride parades are everyone in the lgbt community coming together, and being allowed to be themselves in public. I could hole my girlfriend's hand and not worry about getting stares (or worse). Pride parades are about community, not labels.

    Everyone is welcome at pride parades. Yes, there are some people that support the stereotypes of 'bear', or 'twink', or 'dyke'. But stereotypes exist because there are some people actually like that.

    I agree with you. Labels are AWFUL. I hate them. They stress everyone out (am I gay? am I bi?) and matter so little.

    But Pride has little to do with labels. I highly suggest you try and go to a pride parade. :)

    I am proud of being gay because I no longer have to hide. I no longer have to worry about being KILLED because of my sexuality. Pride has to do with being in a suppressed state and being able to overcome that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your perspective, Alice. A big problem that I foresaw when I started this blog was that I really wasn't that involved in the gay community - I haven't been to any pride parades, so I guess I was only addressing the image of them that's portrayed by TV and the media.

      Still, I think part of my point was that pride parades shouldn't have to exist; I don't think that there should be a certain time and place where it's okay to "be" gay - it should be ALL the time. And while I definitely believe that pride parades are common ground in which people can come together as a community - which IS beneficial - it's just that, from my perspective, it inevitably leads to this idea of distinguishing lgbt sexualities as a separate part of "normal" society.

      What I really mean is that you should be as proud of being gay as you are of being human - because they're the same thing. I'm not saying you shouldn't be proud of it, but if I wanted someone to think of me as "normal" - which being gay IS - then I wouldn't behave any differently in regards to my sexuality. However, I do think that overcoming the challenges posed by an intolerant society is something to be very proud of.

      I really appreciate your comments! :)

      Delete
    2. I definitely see you're point. In a perfect world, you would be absolutely right.

      I also would like to clarify that I wasn't attempting to criticize or argue, just throwing out a different point of view.

      Pride parades still give a sense of belonging and community one doesn't normally feel. And I don't know about where you live, but I DON'T feel comfortable being who I am on a regular basis. Pride is like a sanctuary.

      And you're right, it shouldn't be something you need to feel 'proud' about, but I think you are taking the word proud to be too... literal? Something. Lol. It's like having pride in your country. You didn't do anything to influence your countries history or anything, yet you can still have pride in it. Being a Canadian doesn't make me 'nonhuman' or anything, being a proud Canadian isn't much different than being a proud homosexual.

      Just food for thought

      Delete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete